Can god lift a stone too heavy

Author: gwiy

August undefined, 2024

WebJun 24, 2024 · Can an omnipotent being create a stone so heavy that it cannot lift it? If yes: the being's power is limited, because it cannot lift the stone. ... Taking into consideration the interpretation that "God makes a rock too heavy for him at the present moment, but gives himself the power to carry said rock after it was created" still solves nothing ... WebMar 21, 2014 · The lifting action doesn't apply to Allah (c.c) in it's literal sense, because Allah (c.c) doesn't need to overcome gravity, because, Allah decides how physics works. The notion of existence of a rock, which Allah (c.c) can't lift, requires physics, outside of Allah's (c.c) control. This idea doesn't apply to God.

Can God Create a Stone Too Heavy for Himself To Lift?

WebAnswer (1 of 3): My answer is ‘yes’ there are stones God cannot pick up. How so? I mean God is sovereign and omnipotent, so it doesn’t make sense right? We see that God is … WebMar 27, 2024 · Can God make a rock so heavy that not even he could lift it? Atterton notes, “If God can create such a stone, then he is not all powerful, since he himself cannot lift it. On the other hand, if he cannot create a stone that cannot be lifted, then he is not all-powerful, since he cannot create the unliftable stone. Either way, God is not all ... how does lack of capital affect business

Can God Create A Rock So Heavy That He Cannot Lift It? - Cross …

WebNo God cannot create a rock that he cannot lift. But just because he can't do this doesn't mean he's not all powerful, just that he can't do the logically impossible. Descartes gives … WebAnswer: God’s omnipotence extends to all things that do not involve a logical contradiction. Since the idea of God creating a rock that is too heavy for him to lift involves a logical contradiction, it’s not subject to his omnipotence. This doesn’t count against his omnipotence anymore than the claim that God can’t make a square circle. WebSimply put, the argument hinges on the question of whether or not God is capable of creating a stone too heavy for him to lift. If he can, he isn’t all-powerful since he would … photo of ariana grande

Could God create a rock so heavy He could not lift it?

Extract 3: Omnipotence, God and the heavy stone

WebCreating a stone too heavy for its creator to lift is a possible task. ... God can do the logically impossible, then God can create a stone too heavy for him to lift and still lift it. Funkhouser, Eric. 2006. On privileging God’s moral … WebBut if God can lift any stone, then again there appears to be one task God cannot do, namely create a stone too heavy for God to lift. The argument concludes there cannot … photo of archie nowWebBut if God can lift any stone, then again there appears to be one task God cannot do, namely create a stone too heavy for God to lift. The argument concludes there cannot be an omnipotent God. The most plausible and common philosophical response to this puzzle is to challenge the coherence of the task demanded. photo of archie prince

"WebIf God can create such a stone, then He is not all powerful, since He Himself cannot lift it. On the other hand, if He cannot create a stone that cannot be lifted, then He is not all … " - Can god lift a stone too heavy

Can god lift a stone too heavy

WebSimilarly, God has the power to do as He wishes. However, the objects involved are too weak to accept the power of God. In the case of the stone paradox, the problem lies in … WebNov 24, 2012 · And if God cannot create the stone too heavy for him to lift, there is still something he cannot do (in this case, create the stone). Either God can or cannot create such a stone. Therefore, in either case, there is something God cannot do; and in either case, we seem forced to conclude that God is not omnipotent” (Ronald Nash, 47).

Did you know?

WebGod can make a stone too heavy for God to lift. Or, at least, God can make it appear that way. God creates through a deficiency of union-- or an illusion of deficiency. So, God could certainly form an illusion of deficiency weak enough that it couldn't even lift a pebble. WebJun 13, 2011. #4. God can create a stone, then promise not to lift it. It's not "too heavy," but it "cannot be lifted by God" at that point because God has promised not to do it. …

Webposition about whether God exists and/or what God is like. A Second Approach Uses philosophical tools to analyze theological claims, evaluate them for consistency, and … WebThis question is frequently asked by skeptics of God, the Bible, Christianity, etc. If God can create a rock that He cannot lift, then God is not omnipotent. If God cannot create a …

WebOne may as well ask if a god could create a stone so purple he can't lift it. Of course, that just applies to the version of it that specifies that the stone be too heavy for god to lift. Versions which simplify it (as the one in this … WebAug 13, 2024 · Similarly, God has the power to do as He wishes. However, the objects involved are too weak to accept the power of God. In the case of the stone paradox, the problem lies in the stone as the stone does not have the capacity to absorb the power it would require for it to have so much weight that God cannot lift it.

WebMay 15, 2024 · Jun 13, 2011. #4. God can create a stone, then promise not to lift it. It's not "too heavy," but it "cannot be lifted by God" at that point because God has promised not to do it. Nothing is impossible for God; but He can choose to make something abhorrent to His nature and therefore "undoable" for Him. Report.

WebThere is no upper limit to what God can lift. Thus a stone too heavy for God to lift would have to have more than infinite weight, and the idea of “more than infinite” weight … how does lack of exercise affect healthWebAnd, if one believes that god is omnipotent, then this question is irrelevant because this question is a contradiction. Because, if gods omnipotent then there is no stone too … photo of archie with chickensWebDec 9, 2002 · It is God's infinite power (omnipotence) that makes the creation of a stone impossible while we, as men with finite power, can make objects too heavy for us to lift. If we do not assume that God is omnipotent we can still give up a small amount of omnipotence (if this is indeed possible) and retain that God is omnipotent in lifting stone … how does lack of education cause crimeWebGod can create a stone so heavy he can't lift it. Then he will lift up this too heavy stone. God is not an either/or, God just is. 1. Share. Report Save. level 2 · 8y. See this is what I'm trying to get at. Although I think it is still a paradox, what I'm trying to say is that this would be of little concern to God. 1. how does lack of exercise affect asthmaWebJan 12, 2008 · The basic answer is: An all powerful God can do or make any thing, but it's meaningless to say that he can do or make a nothing. A logically contradictory state of affairs is not a thing at all, but NOTHING. The point is, ‘a rock too heavy for God to lift’ is really ‘a rock too heavy for a being who can lift anything’, so it is a self ... how does lack of exercise cause asthmaWebhttp://reasonablefaith.org - Can God Make a Stone So Heavy He Can't Lift It? Dr. William Lane Craig answers a question about God's attribute. In this case, H... photo of arctic foxWebIt attempts to demonstrate that a being with infinite power is a contradiction and so cannot really exist. If, for instance, we say that God can create a stone too heavy for Him to … photo of arduino